You are only as cool as the music that you listen to, though.
Say, if you were to say that you enjoy the musical stylings of Maroon 5, I'd think that you were either gay or a gay girl who doesn't know that she's gay yet.
If you said that you liked The Turtles, I'd consider you a weirdo and consider my own musical tastes to be comparatively normal. Then we'd have stimulating conversation about whatever.
If you said that you liked Genghis Tron, we'd meet up somewhere and melt G.I. Joes together and be 'BFFL'.